© All rights reserved to Barnea Jaffa Lande Law offices
Together is powerful

The Hague Convention: Proposed Rules on Choice of Court Agreements and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments

Summary

  • Israel’s Ministry of Justice has published a draft bill implementing the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements. The bill would limit Israeli courts’ discretion when enforcing exclusive choice of court agreements in international commercial contracts.
  • The proposed framework is expected to make it easier to enforce Israeli judgments in countries party to the Convention. It may also make it harder for Israeli companies to litigate in Israel contrary to a foreign choice of court agreement.
  • The change may also affect existing contracts, particularly those involving companies from EU member states, the United Kingdom, and Switzerland.
  • Companies are advised to review the choice of court provisions in their existing and new contracts. Comments on the draft bill may be submitted until November 24, 2026.

On November 4, 2026, Israel’s Ministry of Justice published for public comment the Draft Bill for the Implementation of Convention on Choice of Court Agrrements, 5787-2026. The bill aims to incorporate into Israeli law the Hague Convention on Choice of Court Agreements of June 30, 2005. Israel signed the Convention on March 3, 2021, but has not yet ratified it. According to the Hague Conference’s table of parties, the Convention currently has 38 states and the European Union as parties, including all EU member states, the United Kingdom, Switzerland, Singapore, Mexico, and Ukraine. The United States and China have signed but not ratified the Convention.

 

The bill’s principal change is a significant reduction in courts’ discretion when enforcing exclusive choice of court agreements in international commercial contracts covered by the Convention. It also creates a uniform mechanism for recognizing and enforcing foreign judgments. These changes may have significant implications for Israeli companies operating in international markets.

 

Choice of Court Agreements and Enforcement of Judgments – What Is Expected to Change?

According to the draft bill’s explanatory notes, Israeli case law tends to respect foreign choice of court agreements but leaves courts broad discretion in exceptional cases. The Foreign Judgments Enforcement Law, 5718-1958, does not establish a specific framework for judgments issued pursuant to a choice of court agreement. The bill proposes a single framework for both matters and provides that the Convention’s provisions will apply “notwithstanding any provision of law” (Section 3(a)).

 

 

Issue

Existing law

Under the draft bill and the Convention

Exclusive foreign choice of court agreement

Courts generally respect the agreement but may depart from it, including on grounds of public policy, mandatory law, or forum non conveniens.

The court must stay or dismiss the proceedings unless one of the five exceptions in Article 6 of the Convention applies, including where enforcing the agreement would lead to “manifest injustice” or be “manifestly” incompatible with public policy.

Exclusivity of the choice of court agreement

A question of contractual interpretation for the court.

The agreement is presumed exclusive unless the parties have expressly provided otherwise (Article 3(b) of the Convention).

Chosen Israeli court

The law does not provide a specific framework.

The court may not decline to hear the dispute on the grounds that it should be heard in another country (Article 5(2) of the Convention).

Timing of an application to stay proceedings

Governed by general procedural rules.

The application must be made no later than the party’s first pleading containing arguments on the merits (Section 5 of the draft bill).

Enforcement of a foreign judgment in Israel

Governed by the Foreign Judgments Enforcement Law and its conditions, including reciprocity and public policy.

Judgments must be recognized and enforced, subject to the Convention’s grounds for refusal and without review of the merits. The Foreign Judgments Enforcement Law will not apply to judgments covered by the proposed framework.

Authentication of documents

An apostille or other authentication is generally required.

Documents are exempt from authentication (Article 18 of the Convention); alternatives will be prescribed by regulations.

Israeli judgment abroad

Enforced under the local law of each country.

Recognized and enforced in countries party to the Convention, provided the judgment falls within its scope and subject to its exceptions.

 

 

The proposed bill does not affect agreements designating a court in a country that is not party to the Convention, including the United States and China. Existing law will continue to apply to those agreements. In addition, the Convention does not apply to arbitration or govern interim measures (Articles 2(4) and 7). A separate bill introduced in the Knesset would implement the 2019 Hague Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments. That Convention does not apply to judgments issued pursuant to an exclusive choice of court agreement, so the two frameworks are complementary.

 

 

Entry into Force and Effect on Existing Contracts

The draft bill is at the first stage of the legislative process and is not yet binding. Following the public comment period, the bill would require approval by the Ministerial Committee for Legislation and would need to pass three readings in the Knesset. Israel would also need to ratify the Convention. Under Article 31, the Convention will enter into force for Israel on the first day of the month following the expiration of three months after Israel deposits its instrument of ratification. No timetable has been set for these steps.

 

 

A key component of the proposed framework has yet to be formulated: the Second Schedule, which will specify the matters Israel intends to exclude from the Convention under Article 21. According to the bill’s explanatory notes, work on the exclusions is underway, and the schedule will be incorporated into the bill before its first reading. Such a declaration applies reciprocally and will therefore also affect the enforcement of Israeli judgments abroad.

 

 

The proposed framework may also affect existing contracts. Under Article 16, the Convention applies to agreements concluded after it entered into force in the state of the chosen court and to proceedings brought after it entered into force in the state holding those proceedings. For example, an agreement signed in 2020 designating a court in Germany or France may fall within the Convention’s scope if proceedings are brought in Israel after the Convention enters into force there. The presumption of exclusivity may also apply. An agreement designating an Israeli court will benefit from the Convention only if it is concluded after the Convention enters into force in Israel.

 

 

Which Companies and Sectors Are Likely to Be Affected?

The primary beneficiaries are Israeli companies that contract with parties from the European Union, the United Kingdom, or Switzerland under agreements containing an exclusive choice of court provision specifying that disagreements would be litigated in Israeli courts. Once the Convention enters into force in Israel, enforcement of judgments within its scope will be subject to uniform rules and defined grounds for refusal.

 

 

Conversely, a weaker party to a business contract may be adversely affected. For example, an Israeli distributor, agent, franchisee, supplier, or subcontractor may have signed a large European partner’s standard agreement designating the courts in that partner’s country. Today, that party may argue in Israel that the provision should not be enforced, including on grounds of public policy or mandatory law—statutory provisions that cannot be contracted out of. Once the Convention enters into force in Israel, if it applies to the arrangement, the party will need to establish that one of its exceptions applies. For example, the party may need to show that enforcing the agreement would lead to “manifest injustice” or be “manifestly” incompatible with public policy.

 

 

Article 2 excludes certain matters from the Convention’s scope. These include consumer and employment contracts; the carriage of passengers and goods, including bills of lading and air and sea transport; insolvency; competition matters; rights in rem in immovable property; and the validity of intellectual property rights other than copyright. By contrast, a contractual dispute over a patent or software license may fall within the Convention’s scope, as may an infringement claim that could also have been brought as a contractual claim.

 

 

Two other sectors will be affected in part:

  • Insurance sector: The European Union has declared that it will not apply the Convention to insurance contracts, except for reinsurance, large risks, and agreements concluded after a dispute has arisen. The declaration applies reciprocally.
  • Financial institutions: Financing agreements often contain an asymmetric choice of court provision, requiring the borrower to litigate in one forum while allowing the lender to sue elsewhere. Such a provision is not likely to be considered “exclusive” within the meaning of the Convention. In such case, existing law will continue to apply.

 

 

How Should Companies Prepare?

First, consider submitting comments on the draft bill. Public comments will be accepted through the government’s legislation website until 2:00 p.m. on November 24, 2026. The preparation of the list of exclusions gives companies an opportunity to express their views, including on whether Israel should adopt the European insurance exclusion or establish special protection for weaker parties to business contracts.

 

Second, review existing contracts. Companies should examine choice of court provisions designating courts in countries party to the Convention. A provision assumed to be non-exclusive, but not expressly stated to be so, may prevent a party from bringing proceedings in Israel. In such cases, companies should consider agreeing to amend the provision before ratification.

 

Third, reconsider whether to use a choice of court provision or an arbitration clause in new contracts. When contracting with parties from countries subject to the Convention, an exclusive choice of court provision in favor of an Israeli court may provide greater certainty about enforcing judgments abroad—previously a key advantage of arbitration. It may also preserve a right of appeal. For arrangements with parties from countries not subject to the Convention, international arbitration may continue to offer advantages when enforcing an award. Companies that may need interim measures abroad should also remember that the Convention does not govern them.

 

Fourth, respond promptly to proceedings. Under the proposed framework, a company sued in Israel contrary to a foreign choice of court agreement will need to request a stay no later than its first pleading on the merits. A party that first defends the claim on the merits may lose the protection afforded by the Convention.

 

The bill is still in the early stages of the legislative process, but contracts signed today may be subject to its provisions in the future. Companies operating in international markets are therefore advised to review the dispute resolution mechanisms in their commercial arrangements now, with appropriate legal advice. They should consider not only where proceedings will be conducted, but also how judgments may be enforced, the costs of resolving disputes, and the associated legal risks.

 

***

 

Prof. Amichai Cohen is the firm’s special counsel for international law. He specializes in international law, the implications of international treaties, and the impact of international legal and regulatory developments on companies’ operations.

 

Barnea Lande’s international law team advises Israeli and foreign companies on their cross-border business activities, including the applicability of international treaties, the drafting of choice of court and choice of law provisions, the selection of dispute resolution mechanisms, and the recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments. The team combines expertise in international law, commercial law, and international litigation to reduce clients’ exposure and strengthen their legal certainty.

 

Tags: International Law | Sanctions
Barnea
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.